No glass ceilings: Tackling persistent disadvantage
Care, belief and practical support help persistently disadvantaged pupils thrive in Axminster.
As Headteacher of Axe Valley Academy in Devon, Rob Crocker leads a school in a community where long-term poverty and limited local opportunities can create significant challenges. Persistently disadvantaged pupils in the South West achieve, on average, a Grade 3.1 in Key Stage 4 English and Maths – 1.8 lower than their non-disadvantage peers. In his own words, he shares how the school supports persistently disadvantaged pupils through practical help, strong relationships and a culture built on care, ambition and belief.
Rob's story
I'm Rob, Headteacher at Axe Valley Academy. We’re a school in Devon situated near the intersection of Devon, Somerset and Dorset. We have students that come from all three of those local authorities. The school has had a period of significant growth, at roughly 750 students, growing to about 800 next academic year.
The Axe Valley community
The school is in a small rural market town. There's little employment in the local area outside of skilled trades which tend to be the predominant industry here. There aren't any big employers here anymore, and that can create a challenging landscape for children.
32% of our children qualify for pupil premium, and about 31.5% are current free school meals students. The vast majority are currently experiencing poverty and struggling as a result. We also have high levels of SEND (Special Educational Needs and Disabilities) for a mainstream school. 33% of our children are on the SEND register with high numbers of EHCPs (Education, Health and Care Plans) as well.
We know that our local area has high levels of deprivation because we track the data quite carefully around the Income Deprivation Affecting Children Index (IDACI).
The reality for local families
Persistent Disadvantage means experiencing disadvantage throughout the majority of a child’s educational journey, and therefore the impact of poverty is likely to be greater over time.
We serve families where there are issues with generational poverty and issues with worklessness because of lack of opportunities in the local area.
There's some awareness of persistent disadvantage from our students because society ingrains that within young people. But we provide uniform, food and equipment, and provide funded access to trips and activities – so that from a student perspective, there is no noticeable or knowable difference.
High expectations and strong support
Our job is to try and make sure that we're doing everything we can to challenge and support children and families – give them high aspirations and make sure that they're headed to meaningful destinations, but also provide all of the support and wraparound care to help them achieve.
For me, that’s the measure of a good school – providing support to those that need it the most.
And that flows through everything that we do. We want to know their barriers, and we want to be the solution.
The school’s rurality means that it struggles with access to services and infrastructure. Lots of the local hubs, services and centres don't stretch this far because we're right on the east edge of the local authority. We try and fill that gap in any way possible to make sure that our families get the best.
We know that persistent disadvantage can lead to food insecurity, which can lead to issues around concentration or attendance, or just feeling hungry. So, we feed children at every opportunity.
We know that sometimes there can be aspiration gaps, particularly where there is generational disadvantage, and we need to make sure that we're providing that “no glass ceilings” approach for children and showing them the range of things that are ready for them when they leave us.
We know that sometimes persistently disadvantaged students require us to build greater trust with their families, because of their family's negative experiences of education or with authority figures.
It takes a lot of positive communication, but also a lot of support for families and reassurance. Trying to bring families on site as much as possible to show them the work that we're doing and to be there for them in any way.
Supporting persistently disadvantaged pupils
We’ve recently been successful in garnering better attendance to parents' evenings for our persistently disadvantaged children. We asked students and parents: what's making parents' evening tricky for you?
Some of it was around views around their own educational experiences, so we made sure there were targeted phone calls, home visits and meetings with those families to share good things, rather than waiting for meetings which could be challenging. That strategy's had a real impact this year.
Alongside that, what mattered loud and clear was parents' access to childcare. Often our persistently disadvantaged children are from single parent families, and parents evening was difficult because they had other children to look after.
Thinking outside the box, we provide fish and chips for all our disadvantaged families on parents’ evenings, and we partnered with a local nursery to run a free on-site creche.
We’ve launched an Activities Week this year for the first time this year because we wanted to increase opportunities for all our children.
We also reflected on some of the Equity Scorecard work that's come out of Exeter University around not always asking disadvantaged families to request financial support, because sometimes that can be a barrier in itself. So, we offered bursaries to all of our disadvantaged families as well as additional funding.
We commissioned financial support from local charitable organisations to be able to pay for families or children to do the activities that they want to do and have those experiences that they want to do. That's working well.
We've implemented a phone free solution this academic year, with phones being locked away. That has genuinely had an impact on student mental health. Our persistently disadvantaged children, who were more likely to experience poor mental health, now have more positivity around school and socialisation within school.
Looking beyond the classroom
We know that our persistently disadvantaged children are more likely to be persistently absent, and that absenteeism affects their outcomes.
We put a lot of work into making sure that students get the support that they need around mental health, food security and signposting to external services if they're struggling to access them. We make sure that school is a place of joy and fun and always has something positive to offer.
We also know health issues are more likely to happen for our persistently disadvantaged students and accessing health in a small market town is quite difficult. So, we work carefully with external providers and agencies to champion our kids and champion our families. We shout loudly so that they don't feel left out and can get the support that they need. We track our disadvantaged data all the way through school. At every reporting point, in Key Stage 3 and Key Stage 4, we always use that data to target intervention in the right way and minimise gaps as much as possible.
Our basic data for disadvantaged children is strong and we're proud of that. We find opportunities to work out which students need support, and we target our interventions as cleverly and carefully as possible to spot any emerging gaps and manage them.
Belief changes lives
Our school’s difference is our belief – we are constantly narrating aspiration and ambition and that life can be challenging, but with the right support and the right belief, anybody can go anywhere.
As a staff body, we want all our children to believe in themselves, but we'll say to them: when you're struggling to believe in yourselves, we'll believe in you for you.
Our culture is positive and there's no stigma between children. They understand each other's needs and they understand that other children have different things happening and they will come and champion each other.
Children will tell us: I'm really worried about so and so because they told me last night they weren't able to have dinner. They care about each other deeply.
They know that we'll then do something to try and support that young person and try and help them. We've got a culture here where we want to help everybody to succeed.
Putting disadvantaged pupils first
Every part of our school improvement model and evaluation framework starts with the experiences of disadvantaged children, and that's the thing we focus on.
Disadvantaged students are always the first thing we look at when it comes to attendance, all our data, outcomes or midpoint tracking...everything.
We obviously care about all children, but we go to our disadvantaged students first and then we explore everything else.
When we get provision right for our disadvantaged students, we get provision right for everybody.
We put them at the front of our thinking at every opportunity and that flows through all the documentation that we produce for staff.
We prioritise what's important for getting things right for children. That comes with a significant cost, but it's the right thing to do.
Roughly 65% of our disadvantaged students that join us on entry are not at age-related expectations for reading. We invest a lot of money into literacy and reading intervention to help children access the curriculum, be successful and continue a positive trajectory into Key Stage 4.
Changing the trajectory
Education is the thing that will make a difference. For many children, particularly from persistently disadvantaged backgrounds, education is possibly the only thing that can change that early trajectory for their first careers or their opportunities to go into the world of further education or higher education.
So it's absolutely our responsibility. It's hard for schools to manage gaps that exist within other areas of the state, but schools are the right place to do that because schools are the ones that can know families in the best possible way and the ones that are at the hearts of their communities to be able to make a difference for children.
But for me, genuinely, the most important thing is communicating care and worth, because those are two things that help young people believe in themselves.
Help us rewrite the future
Join our campaign to help children in long-term poverty have the best chance at a brighter future. Start by downloading our report to see our in-depth research and other stand out schools. Then, we need you to support us in this mission so please make your pledge below.
Together, let's rewrite the future for children facing persistent disadvantage.